We ate here with a party of 6 for 2 people in our group with birthdays. We did make a reservation since it was a larger group, and we were seated at a beautiful table right in the front with a lot of windows. Our server was wonderful, took a picture of our group with my phone. Drinks were wonderful (and all day Sunday is Happy Hour so that we great!), and we absolutely loved the appetizers we ordered. Pizzas took a bit to come out, but that was expected since it was 4 pizzas coming out at once time.... but they were well worth the wait!! Some of the best pizza we have ever had!! We will definitely return again and highly recommend!! We want to thank you for making a great lunch for 2 birthdays! So glad we chose to eat here!!

Eat here!!! We had an incredible experience at Wicked Pie Pizza! Nestled in a vibrant, walkable part of Puyallup with plenty of street and free lot parking, it’s a cozy, welcoming spot. The seating options are varied and comfortable, and the fun, kitschy decor and lighting create a unique, laid-back vibe. Lew, the owner, greeted us warmly and made sure we felt right at home. He let us settle in before bringing drinks — the current cider on draft (cranberry, cherry, and honey notes from Eastern Washington) was outstanding and comes highly recommended. We decided on The Chosen One pizza and were surprised to learn there are two different recipes — both are a must-try, but we won’t spoil the surprise! The creativity and flavor blew us away. Throughout dinner, all we could say to each other was “wow,” “this is amazing,” and “we’re bringing everyone we know here.” Wicked Pie Pizza came highly recommended to us by friends and from countless online mentions — and they absolutely lived up to the hype. With awards under their belt, it’s clear why. Lew has truly created something special — a place that feels like a home away from home, with incredible food to match. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!

We love wicked pie. I do kind of wish they allowed kids during the day though. Pizza is always consistently good. Love a brick oven pizza. The pizza is expensive though. It'd be nice if they had smaller portions or mix and matches so we could try more flavors of pizza.

Amazingly tasty pizza! Stopped by yesterday in the middle of the rolling car show, place was packed. Still got seated quickly enough. Food was perfectly prepared and came out quickly, impressive for how busy they were. Thr service was great as well. Our server was very attentive, timely, kind and fun! She understood the assignment for sure. Loved her. But it doesn't stop there. We had meatball app, super tasty and flavorful. Followed by 2 large pizzas, both perfectly cooked and prepared. Ao delicious. Leftovers today, reheated in the oven are just as good. Highly reccomend without any hesitation!

The best pizza in Puyallup hands down. The “Say it ain’t so” pizza with added pepperoni is our favorite. It’s a combination of ingredients we’d never order normally. But Wicked Pie makes it phenomenal. The adult only atmosphere makes it a great date night restaurant. The customer service has always been top notch too. You can’t go wrong dining here!

The wait time went by quick. It's loud & bustling inside but still a great experience... pizza was so good!!! Salad was SO fresh!!! Cheesy bread was BOMB! Even my margarita was delicious!!! Definitely need to come back & try the rest of the menu.

Wonderful experience this afternoon at Wicked Pie, we sat outside and enjoyed the good weather and sunshine. Large garden salad split and Large Mixed Feelings Pizza ( pepperoni, sausage, black olives and mushrooms). Pizza was cooked to perfection and we took half home. We will return soon!

The Best pizza you will find! The people are so Friendly and welcoming the vibe is so fun! Service is spot on! Highly recommend! Salads are bomb too! And aperol spritz they make them the Best! You can sit outside in the sun now too on sunny days!